Pokémon Trading Cards

No products found
Use fewer filters or remove all

man holding a box of electronics

Sell Pokémon cards for cash in Bensonhurst, NY today!

At PayMore®, selling your Pokémon card collection is simple and reliable. Enjoy instant cash payments at competitive rates when you visit with your cards. PayMore® guarantees accurate appraisals through certified card evaluation, providing peace of mind that your collection receives proper assessment. The efficient process is designed for convenience, making PayMore® your trusted choice in Bensonhurst for transforming Pokémon cards into immediate cash.

Directions to PayMore Bensonhurst, NY
paymore employee holding a tablet and smiling

PayMore Stores® Guarantee

All our devices are genuine, rigorously tested, and fully functional. Additionally, every device you purchase from us is backed by a 30-day warranty for your peace of mind. If you're looking to sell your old electronics, we'll provide you with a top-dollar instant cash offer while ensuring your data remains secure.

Pokémon Card FAQs

What are the Pokémon card types?

Pokémon cards come in three main types: Pokémon, Trainer, and Energy cards. Pokémon cards represent creatures used in battle and come in different elemental types (like Fire, Water, or Electric). Trainer cards support gameplay with effects or tools. Energy cards power a Pokémon’s attacks.

How are Pokémon card values determined?

Card values are based on rarity, condition, edition, demand, and whether the card is graded. Factors like being a 1st Edition, having a holographic finish, or being competitively viable can increase value. Popularity of the Pokémon and current market trends also play a role.

Is 1st Edition better than Unlimited?

Yes, 1st Edition cards are usually more valuable than Unlimited cards. They were printed in smaller quantities and marked with a “1st Edition” stamp, making them more collectible and desirable to buyers.

How do graded Pokémon cards work?

Graded cards are professionally evaluated for condition and authenticity by services like PSA, CGC, or Beckett. Cards receive a numeric score (typically 1–10), sealed in a tamper-proof case. Higher grades, especially 9 or 10, can significantly increase a card’s value.

What is the difference between Holo, Reverse Holo, and Non-Holo Pokémon cards?

  • Holo (Holographic): The artwork of the Pokémon is shiny.
  • Reverse Holo: The artwork is matte, but the rest of the card is holographic.
  • Non-Holo: No holographic effect—entirely flat finish. Holos and Reverse Holos tend to be more sought after than Non-Holos.

Should I get my Pokémon cards graded before selling them?

It depends. Grading adds value to rare, vintage, or mint-condition cards. But for modern or lower-value cards, grading may cost more than the potential increase in value. If you're unsure, bring them into PayMore—we'll help you decide if grading is worth it.

Can I sell my Pokémon cards to PayMore Bensonhurst?

Yes! Visit your nearest PayMore store with your cards, and we’ll evaluate them and offer you cash or store credit on the spot.

Do I need an appointment to sell Pokémon cards?

No appointment needed. Just walk in with your collection during store hours.

How does PayMore Bensonhurst determine the value of my Pokémon cards?

We assess condition, rarity, demand, edition, and recent market trends to determine the fair market value of your cards.

Does PayMore Bensonhurst accept graded Pokémon cards?

Yes, we buy graded cards from PSA, BGS, and CGC. Higher grades typically command higher offers.

Can I sell an entire Pokémon card collection?

Definitely. Whether it’s a few cards or hundreds, we’re happy to review your entire collection.

Can I sell my sealed products?

Of course, we buy sealed products such as Elite Trainer Boxes, Booster Boxes, Tech Sticker Packs, Poster Collections, and more.

Can I trade my Pokémon cards for electronics?

Yes! Not only do we offer cash, but you can also trade in your electronics for store credit and use it toward anything we have in stock.